A 64-Year-Old Couple With $1.7 Million in a 401(k) Just Realized They’ve Been Drawing It Down in the Wrong Order
The conventional wisdom on which retirement account to tap first works fine until your 401(k) grows large enough to turn the government into a silent partner. This couple at 64 discovered they had a closing window to change that outcome…
This post may contain links from our sponsors and affiliates, and Flywheel Publishing may receive compensation for actions taken through them.
A couple recently posted a familiar dilemma on a retirement forum: both 64, roughly $1.7 million in a 401(k), a small Roth, and a taxable brokerage account they’ve been draining first because that is what every book told them to do. The math they ran last month made them stop cold. Drawing accounts in the conventional order (taxable, then tax-deferred, then Roth) is quietly setting up a seven-figure tax bill they can still avoid, but only if they act in the next few years.
The sequence is what drives the outcome.
Why the Standard Playbook Backfires at $1.7 Million
The textbook order was designed for portfolios where the tax-deferred account would not balloon into an RMD problem. At $1.7 million with another nine years of compounding before required minimum distributions begin at 73, that assumption collapses. If the 401(k) grows at 7%, the balance roughly doubles by the time RMDs start. The first mandatory withdrawal alone lands well into six figures, stacks on top of Social Security, and drags a chunk of that benefit into taxation.
Then Medicare joins the party. IRMAA uses a two-year lookback on modified adjusted gross income, so the RMD that hits at 73 sets the Medicare premium surcharge at 75. A couple in the 22% bracket who trips both Social Security taxation and the first IRMAA tier faces an effective marginal rate closer to 40% on every additional dollar. The conventional withdrawal order feeds this tax cascade.
Bracket Space You Are Wasting Right Now
The 2026 code gives a married couple filing jointly meaningful room to work with. The standard deduction is $32,200, and the brackets step up from there — 12%, 22%, and 24% — before the 32% cliff arrives at the top of the 24% band.
A 64-year-old couple with no earned income and no Social Security yet has almost all of that bracket space sitting empty. Every dollar of 401(k) withdrawal or Roth conversion between now and age 72 that fills the 12% and 22% brackets is a dollar that will not be forced out at 24% or higher once RMDs and Social Security stack together. Roughly $133,000 of 401(k) money can come out each year at a blended rate near 10% after the standard deduction — filling the 12% bracket that runs to $100,800 of taxable income. Push to the top of the 22% bracket, which extends to $211,400, and the couple can move about $243,000 annually at a blended rate closer to 17%. The 24% bracket extends to $403,550 before the 32% cliff.
Compare that to the 32% or 35% they will pay later on the same dollars, plus IRMAA surcharges, plus taxable Social Security. You withdraw from the 401(k) in your mid-60s because the bracket space itself is a wasting asset.
Bridge Years Are the Whole Game
The window between retirement and RMDs, roughly ages 64 through 72 for this couple, is when withdrawal sequencing gets decided. Wes Moss made the point bluntly on a recent podcast when a listener with a similar profile described converting only enough to stay under the 24% bracket: “if you’re already almost at those levels, then your Roth conversion is going to be more like 24, 32” once you factor in living expenses on top of the conversion. Model the conversion inside your full income picture, not in isolation.
Delaying Social Security to 70 helps here too. It keeps provisional income low during the conversion years, and the delayed benefit grows about 8% annually. With the 2027 COLA tracking toward 3.1%, the future benefit gets larger in real terms while the couple burns through 401(k) dollars at today’s brackets.
Cash needs during the conversion years can be parked in short Treasuries. The 10-year yield near 4.7% means the taxable account and any bond ladder can carry living expenses without forcing you to sell equities into a down market.
Three Moves to Make Before Year-End
- Project the RMD, not the balance. Run the 401(k) forward at a realistic growth rate to age 73 and calculate the first RMD using the IRS Uniform Lifetime Table. If that number plus expected Social Security lands you in the 24% bracket or above, you have a sequencing problem that worsens every year you wait.
- Fill the 22% bracket every year through 72. Withdraw from the 401(k) or convert to Roth up to $211,400 of taxable income (roughly $243,600 gross with the standard deduction). Pay the tax from the taxable account so 100% of the conversion lands in the Roth.
- Watch the first IRMAA threshold once one spouse enrolls in Medicare. The two-year lookback means a conversion at 64 hits Medicare premiums at 66. If a large conversion year pushes MAGI over the first tier, budget for the surcharge in advance rather than discovering it in a billing notice.
The conventional order is fine for a $400,000 401(k). At $1.7 million, the account is large enough that the government becomes your silent partner unless you draw it down on your terms first.
Contact [email protected] for any questions or corrections.
