Instacart Stock Falls 8% After Q1 Earnings. Is the Selloff Overdone?
Key Stats
- Current Price: ~$40 (May 6, 2026 close, down ~8%)
- Q1 2026 GTV: $10.29B, up 13% YoY
- Q1 2026 Total Revenue: $1.02B, up 14% YoY
- Q1 2026 Advertising & Other Revenue: $286M, up 16% YoY
- Q1 2026 Adjusted EBITDA: $300M, up 23% YoY
- Q1 2026 GAAP Net Income: $144M, up 36% YoY
- Q2 2026 GTV Guidance: $10.1B to $10.25B (11% to 13% YoY growth)
- Q2 2026 Adj. EBITDA Guidance: $290M to $300M (11% to 15% YoY growth)
- Q2 2026 Advertising Revenue Guidance: up 11% to 14% YoY
- TIKR Model Price Target: ~$61 (mid case)
- Implied Upside: ~52%
Instacart Stock Just Crossed $1B in Quarterly Revenue. Here’s What the Earnings Show.
Instacart stock (CART) dropped ~8% on May 6, despite Maplebear Inc. reporting Q1 2026 total revenue of $1.02B, up 14% year-over-year and its first time crossing $1B in a single quarter.
GTV hit $10.29B, up 13% YoY, marking the ninth consecutive quarter of double-digit GTV growth and the first time the company surpassed $10B in a single quarter, according to CEO Chris Rogers on the Q1 earnings call.
Advertising and other revenue was $286M, up 16% YoY, the company’s fastest advertising growth rate since Q3 2023, driven by broad-based strength across large, mid-market, and emerging brand cohorts.
Orders reached 91.2 million, up 10% YoY, with average order value of $113, up 3% YoY, supported by strong performance from club retailers and deepening customer engagement.
Adjusted EBITDA came in at $300M, up 23% YoY, while GAAP net income reached $144M, up 36% YoY, reflecting operating leverage across all expense line items.
The company repurchased $349M of shares in Q1 and announced a $1B increase to its buyback authorization, alongside a new $500M unsecured revolving credit facility.
Free cash flow was $253M, down 10% YoY, primarily due to $60M in regulatory settlements paid in Q1 2026 and a favorable accounts receivable collection in the prior-year period that did not repeat.
For Q2 2026, management guided GTV of $10.1B to $10.25B, representing 11% to 13% growth YoY, with advertising revenue expected to grow 11% to 14% YoY.
Q2 adjusted EBITDA guidance of $290M to $300M implies 11% to 15% YoY growth, though CFO Emily Reuter noted Q1 benefited from the late repeal of Canada’s digital services tax, a tailwind that does not carry into Q2.
Management reiterated its full-year target of adjusted EBITDA growing faster than GTV, while flagging that the pace of margin expansion will moderate in 2026 as the company reinvests across multiple growth initiatives.
Instacart Stock Valuation Model Results (TIKR)
The TIKR model prices Instacart stock at ~$61 in the mid case, implying ~52% upside from the May 6 close of ~$40.
The mid case assumes a revenue CAGR of 5.2% through 2035 and a net income margin of 28.5%, with EPS growing at a 7.6% CAGR and the model reaching a stock price of $72 by December 2034.
The low case, at a 4.7% revenue CAGR and 27% net income margin, implies a stock price of ~$58 by 2034, still representing roughly 45% upside from current levels.
The high case, at a 5.8% revenue CAGR and 30.2% net income margin, puts the stock at ~$90 by 2034, a total return of 123%.
Q1’s 16% advertising revenue growth and expanding profitability support the mid-case trajectory, though the ~8% post-earnings decline suggests the market is pricing in Q2 deceleration risk rather than the current run rate.
Whether Instacart stock is undervalued at ~$40 depends almost entirely on whether the advertising and platform ecosystem continues compounding at a rate that justifies the model’s margin expansion assumptions.
Instacart’s investment thesis hinges on one question: can the advertising and data ecosystem scale fast enough to drive margin expansion even as the company reinvests aggressively in AI, international, and in-store?
Low Case
- Advertising revenue growth decelerates from 16% in Q1 toward the low end of Q2 guidance (11%), as brands pull back amid macro uncertainty and ad budgets compress
- The Instaleap acquisition adds international complexity and integration costs before generating meaningful revenue contribution
- Margin expansion moderates materially in 2026 and beyond, with adjusted EBITDA growth tracking toward the low end of the long-term target of 4% to 5% of GTV
- Free cash flow pressure continues as regulatory settlements and reinvestment spending weigh on the 3-year CAGR of 6% the historical model shows
High Case
- The model’s high-case net income margin of 30.2% becomes achievable as operating leverage compounds across shared marketplace and enterprise infrastructure
- Advertising hits the high end of Q2 guidance at 14% growth and sustains that trajectory as the Carrot Ads network expands beyond 310 partners and off-platform partnerships with Meta, The Trade Desk, and TikTok scale
- Storefront Pro’s 10-plus percentage point lift in online sales accelerates retailer adoption internationally, with Costco Spain and France outperforming initial expectations as a proof point
- Cart Assistant, currently live with 25% of U.S. customers, drives higher basket sizes and retention as the agentic shopping experience matures and expands
Should You Invest in Maplebear Inc.?
The only way to really know is to look at the numbers yourself. TIKR gives you free access to the same institutional-quality financial data that professional analysts use to answer exactly that question.
Pull up Instacart stock and you’ll see years of historical financials, what Wall Street analysts expect for revenue and earnings in the quarters ahead, how valuation multiples have moved over time, and whether price targets are trending up or down.
You can build a free watchlist to track Maplebear Inc. alongside every other stock on your radar. No credit card required. Just the data you need to decide for yourself.
Access Professional Tools to Analyze CART stock on TIKR for Free →
